Not All Soy Sauce Is the Same: Your Complete Guide to Every Type

You reach for it automatically. The little dish of dark liquid arrives at the table alongside your sushi, and without much thought, you dip your roll and carry on. Soy sauce feels like a given – a background player, a condiment, a habit.

But here’s the thing: that unassuming dish might be one of the most complex, layered, and misunderstood ingredients in Japanese cuisine. There are multiple distinct types of soy sauce, each with its own flavour profile, colour, texture, and ideal use. The soy sauce a chef uses to glaze a piece of nigiri is probably not the same one that goes into a braising liquid – and it’s almost certainly not the same as what you’ll find in a generic bottle at the grocery store.

So let’s fix that. Here’s everything you actually need to know about soy sauce.

 

First: How Is Soy Sauce Actually Made?

Before you can appreciate the differences between types, it helps to understand what soy sauce even is.

Traditional soy sauce is made by fermenting a mixture of soybeans, wheat, salt, and water. A mould called Aspergillus oryzae – better known as koji – is introduced to kick off fermentation. Over weeks or months (sometimes years for premium varieties), this process breaks down the proteins and starches into amino acids and sugars, producing the sauce’s signature deep flavour.

That flavour isn’t just saltiness. It’s umami – the fifth taste, often described as savoury, rich, and mouthwatering. The longer and more carefully a soy sauce is fermented, the more complex and layered that umami becomes.

Not all soy sauce goes through this process. Cheaper, mass-produced versions use a chemical shortcut: hydrolysed soy protein, which mimics fermentation in a matter of days rather than months. The result tastes flat and one-dimensional compared to the real thing. If you’re buying soy sauce, look for the word naturally brewed on the label – it’s a reliable signal of quality.

 

The Six Types of Soy Sauce You Should Know

1. Koikuchi – The Everyday All-Rounder

What it is: The most common type of Japanese soy sauce, accounting for the vast majority of production in Japan. When most people say “soy sauce,” this is what they mean.

What it tastes like: A balanced combination of saltiness, umami, and a subtle sweetness, with a deep reddish-brown colour. It’s versatile without being extraordinary in any single direction.

Best used for: Pretty much everything. Dipping sushi and sashimi, marinades, stir-fries, glazes, dipping sauces. If a recipe just says “soy sauce,” use koikuchi. It’s also the type most commonly served at Japanese restaurants in North America.

 

2. Usukuchi – The Light One That’s Actually Saltier

What it is: “Usukuchi” translates roughly to “thin taste,” and this style of soy sauce has a noticeably lighter, more amber colour than regular soy sauce. Don’t let that fool you – it’s actually saltier than koikuchi.

What it tastes like: More delicate and less aggressively umami-forward than koikuchi. It has a lighter, cleaner flavour with a higher salt content and is sometimes made with a small amount of sweetener.

Best used for: Dishes where you want to add seasoning without darkening the colour – light soups, clear broths, steamed fish, and delicate sauces. Japanese home cooks use it constantly because it seasons food without turning everything dark brown.

A common mistake: People assume the light colour means it’s lower in sodium. It’s actually the opposite – use it a little more carefully.

 

3. Tamari – The Gluten-Free Option (and So Much More)

What it is: Tamari is the liquid that accumulates as a byproduct of making miso paste. It’s traditionally made with little to no wheat, making it naturally gluten-free or very low in gluten (always check the label to be sure).

What it tastes like: Richer, darker, thicker, and more intensely umami than regular soy sauce. It has a rounder, more complex flavour with less of the sharp, salty edge.

Best used for: Premium dipping – tamari really shines alongside sashimi, where its depth and silkiness complement the fish without overpowering it. It also works beautifully as a finishing sauce or glaze. Because the flavour is more intense, you naturally use less.

Good to know: Tamari is increasingly popular beyond gluten-free diners simply because of its flavour. Many sushi chefs prefer it for dipping over standard soy sauce.

 

4. Shiro – The White Soy Sauce

What it is: Shiro means “white” in Japanese, and this soy sauce lives up to its name – it’s pale gold, almost straw-coloured. It’s made with a much higher proportion of wheat to soybeans, the reverse of tamari.

What it tastes like: Delicate, slightly sweet, and mild. It has the least intense flavour of any soy sauce, with more of a subtle seasoning quality than a bold umami punch.

Best used for: Dishes where you want flavour without colour – white sauces, delicate seafood, light dressings, or presentation-focused dishes where a dark soy sauce would ruin the look. You’ll mostly find this used in professional kitchens rather than home cooking.

 

5. Saishikomi – The Twice-Brewed One

What it is: “Saishikomi” means “twice-brewed,” and that’s exactly what it is – soy sauce that’s been fermented a second time using already-brewed soy sauce instead of salt brine. The result is an intensely concentrated, deeply complex condiment.

What it tastes like: Thick, rich, and almost syrupy, with a deep, complex flavour and a hint of sweetness. It’s sometimes called “sweet soy sauce” in English, though that doesn’t quite capture it.

Best used for: This is a finishing sauce and a premium dipping sauce. Served alongside sashimi or drizzled over nigiri, it’s exceptional. You wouldn’t cook with it – you’d use it to add a final layer of depth to something that doesn’t need heat.

 

6. Chinese Soy Sauce – A Different Family Entirely

What it is: Chinese soy sauce follows different production traditions than Japanese soy sauce and comes in two main varieties: light and dark.

Chinese light soy sauce is thin, very salty, and used as an all-purpose seasoning in Chinese cooking – similar in some ways to koikuchi, but distinctly different in flavour.

Chinese dark soy sauce is aged longer, thicker, less salty, and slightly sweet. It’s primarily used to add colour and a rich, molasses-like flavour to dishes like braised meats, fried rice, and noodles.

Best used for: Chinese cooking. These aren’t interchangeable with Japanese soy sauces in most applications – they have a different flavour DNA and work best in dishes they were designed for.

 

How to Use Soy Sauce with Sushi (You’re Probably Doing It Wrong)

Now that you know your soy sauces, a quick word on how to use them with sushi – because there are a few things most people get wrong.

Dip the fish, not the rice. When eating nigiri, turn the piece upside down and touch the fish to the soy sauce. If you dip rice-side down, the rice absorbs too much sauce, falls apart, and throws off the balance of flavours the chef intended.

Don’t drown it. Soy sauce is a seasoning, not a bath. A light touch lets you taste the fish, the rice, the texture – the full composition of the piece.

Don’t mix wasabi into your soy sauce. This is a very North American habit. The traditional approach is to place a small amount of wasabi directly on the piece if you want heat. Mixing it into the soy sauce dilutes the wasabi and makes precise control impossible.

Pay attention to pre-seasoned pieces. Many good sushi chefs will brush a piece of nigiri directly with soy sauce, ponzu, or a house glaze before serving it. If that’s the case, you don’t need to dip at all – the chef has already done the seasoning for you.

 

The Bottom Line

Soy sauce isn’t one thing. It’s a family of fermented condiments with hundreds of years of tradition behind them, each designed with specific flavours and uses in mind. The difference between a flat, chemically produced supermarket bottle and a well-aged tamari is the difference between processed cheese slices and aged parmesan.

Next time you’re dining at Samurai Sushi, take a moment to appreciate what’s in that little dish. And if you’re cooking Japanese food at home, consider keeping a bottle of tamari alongside your everyday koikuchi – once you try each side by side, you’ll start to understand what all the fuss is about.

Order online

11:00 am - 8:30 pm

Important Notice

For allergy-related orders or orders of $150 or more, please contact your preferred location by phone to place your order.

For delivery orders, please call our Downtown store at 604-567-2002.